Link Building Part of the listicle link building guide
Link insertions and paid listicle spots: what Google allows
What a link insertion is, earned vs paid, what sellers charge, what Google and the FTC say, and when paying for a 'best X' spot is reasonable.
Short answer
A link insertion is a link added to an article that's already published. Asking an editor to add your product to an existing 'best X' list is an earned insertion and is fine. Paying for a followed insertion is link spam under Google's policy; a paid spot is only safe when it's labelled and the link carries rel=sponsored or nofollow.
On this page
A link insertion is a link added to an article that’s already published, instead of a new post written for you. Asking an editor to add your product to an existing “best X” list is an earned insertion and is fine; paying for a followed insertion is what Google’s link spam policy prohibits, so a paid spot is only safe when it’s labelled and tagged rel="sponsored" or nofollow.
This guide is part of our listicle link building hub. It covers the two meanings of “link insertion”, what sellers charge, the three ways money shows up around “best X” posts, what Google and the FTC say about each, and a simple test for when paying is reasonable.
Key takeaways
- “Link insertion” means two things: an editor adding you on merit, or a seller adding you for a fee.
- Earned insertions are normal outreach. Paid, followed insertions are link spam under Google’s policy.
- Google accepts paid links only when they’re tagged
rel="sponsored"ornofollow. - In the US, the FTC expects paid relationships and affiliate links to be disclosed clearly.
- Pay when you’d buy the audience as an ad. Pitch when you want an editorial link.
What is a link insertion?
A link insertion is a link added to a page that already exists. Sellers also call paid ones “niche edits” or “curated links”. The term covers two very different deals, and the difference is whether money or goods changed hands for the link.
| Earned insertion | Paid insertion (niche edit) | |
|---|---|---|
| How it happens | You pitch the editor; they add you because it helps readers | You pay a seller or site owner to place the link |
| Typical target | A “best X” list, an alternatives post, a resource page | Whatever page in the seller’s inventory fits your keyword |
| Google’s view | Normal editorial linking | Link spam unless tagged sponsored or nofollow |
| Who controls it | The editor, who can also remove it | The seller, until the site owner cleans up |
Most listicle outreach is a request for an earned insertion. When you ask to be added to a “best project management tools” post, you’re asking for exactly this. The rest of this guide is about the paid version, because that’s where the risk sits.
What do link insertions cost?
Paid insertions are sold per link, usually priced by the linking site’s metrics. As of October 2026, Rhino Rank’s curated links page lists niche edits and link insertions from $60 per link, described as “contextual dofollow links placed into existing articles”, and its home page lists listicle placements on “best of” pages from $135. Many individual site owners sell insertions too, but rarely publish prices.
Price isn’t the real cost. A followed link that you paid for is the specific thing Google’s policy describes, so the risk sits with your domain whatever the invoice says. Our breakdown of what backlinks cost by method puts these prices next to earned options.
Is a paid link insertion against Google’s rules?
Paying for a placement isn’t against Google’s rules; paying for a link that passes ranking credit is. Google’s spam policies list “buying or selling links for ranking purposes” as link spam, including “exchanging money for links, or posts that contain links”. The same page says buying and selling links “is a normal part of the economy of the web for advertising and sponsorship purposes”, as long as the links are qualified.
Google’s guide to qualifying outbound links sets out the attributes:
| Attribute | Use it for | Google’s guidance |
|---|---|---|
rel="sponsored" |
Ads and paid placements | Preferred for paid links |
rel="nofollow" |
When no other value fits | Still acceptable for paid links |
rel="ugc" |
User-generated content, like comments | Not for paid placements |
The publisher adds the attribute, but if you’re the buyer, get it in writing. Google says sites that violate its policies “may rank lower in results or not appear in results at all”, and buying untagged links is a risk you take on your own domain. You can check what a page actually uses with our nofollow link checker.
What does a risky paid placement look like?
It sells a ranking position plus followed links, with no sponsored label. A public example: on 13 October 2026, Coinranking published a guide on getting crypto projects into best-of lists that offers a #1 listicle placement for $1,499, including “2 do-follow links” and “a Contributor tag, not a sponsored label”. Whatever the audience is worth, payment for a followed link without a sponsored label is the combination Google’s link spam policy describes. If you’re offered a deal like this, ask for rel="sponsored" and a visible label, or walk away.
Should you pay to be included in a ‘best X’ list?
Sometimes, but not for the link. Paying makes sense when the list reaches your buyers, the placement is labelled, and you’d be happy with the traffic alone. It doesn’t make sense if the main reason is a followed backlink, because that’s the thing Google’s policies prohibit, and editors of the most trusted lists don’t sell slots anyway.
There are three deals people call “paying for a listicle”:
| Model | How it works | What you get | Link status you should expect |
|---|---|---|---|
| Pay per placement | A flat fee for a spot, sometimes the top spot | Visibility, a set position | Should be rel="sponsored" or nofollow |
| Affiliate commission | The publisher earns a share of each sale or sign-up they refer | Inclusion often influenced by commission | Usually a tracked link, often sponsored |
| Review marketplace sponsorship | Paid profiles or clicks on sites like Capterra | Traffic and leads from the marketplace | The marketplace controls the link |
For how marketplace profiles compare with editorial lists as link sources, see where SaaS backlinks actually come from.
See which lists you're missing from
The free report finds 'best X', alternatives and comparison posts in your niche that leave you out, with the editor for each.
Get your free prospect reportWhat does the FTC say about paid and affiliate listicles?
In the US, the FTC’s Endorsement Guides require material connections to be disclosed “clearly and conspicuously” when readers wouldn’t expect them (16 CFR 255.5). Material connections include payment and free or discounted products, and the guides’ own examples include a blogger who earns a share of sales through affiliate links.
You can see this on large affiliate publishers. NerdWallet’s invoicing software list says partner compensation “is one of several factors that may affect which products we highlight and where they appear”, while stating that its editors’ ratings are independent. Capterra’s project management category says “software providers pay us for sponsored profiles”.
The publisher makes the disclosure, but the guides also say advertisers “are subject to liability” for failing to disclose unexpected material connections with their endorsers (16 CFR 255.1). If you pay for a placement, ask for the label. This is general information, not legal advice; if you’re spending real money, ask a lawyer.
When is paying reasonable, and when should you pitch instead?
Ask one question: would you buy this placement if it had no link at all? If yes, it’s an advertising decision, and you can judge it like any ad. If no, you’re really buying a backlink, and you should pitch for an earned insertion instead.
| Situation | Better route | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Independent blog, editorial list, no affiliate links | Pitch | Editors here add products on merit |
| Adjacent SaaS company’s roundup | Pitch | They write for readers, not commissions |
| Large affiliate publisher with partner programmes | Join the affiliate programme, then pitch | Commission is part of how they choose; the programme is the honest door |
| Review marketplace (Capterra, G2) | Free listing first, paid only as ad budget | Sponsorship buys traffic, not links |
| Small site sends a rate card after your pitch | Decline, or pay only with a sponsored tag | Some add you later on merit |
| “#1 spot plus do-follow links, no label” | Walk away | Exactly what Google’s link spam policy targets |
To pitch an earned insertion well, start from our guide to getting listed in best-of articles and the listicle inclusion email template.
Should you start an affiliate programme to get listed?
If affiliate publishers cover your category heavily, an affiliate programme is a fair, disclosed way to be considered. It suits products with clear pricing and self-serve sign-up, because publishers need to see conversions to keep you on a list. It won’t get you editorial links from independent writers, and commissions are an ongoing cost, so budget for it like any sales channel.
How do you say no to a paid insertion?
Briefly, and without burning the bridge. Something like: “Thanks for letting me know. We don’t pay for placements, but if you refresh the list and think we’d help your readers, I’d be glad to send anything you need.” Our decline paid link template gives you a ready version, and what to reply when an editor asks for money for a link covers the conversation in more detail.
For buying links outside listicles, our guide to buying backlinks weighs the risks, costs and better options.
How BacklinkGenie handles paid requests
We sell an outreach product, so here is how it treats money. BacklinkGenie is an AI agent that runs link outreach end to end, and its pitches ask for earned mentions on pages where your product fits on merit: “best X” lists, alternatives and comparison posts, resource pages and how-to guides. It doesn’t pitch guest posts, and its quality gate blocks any draft that offers payment for a placement. When an editor replies asking for a fee, the reply is flagged as a paid offer so you see it. Whether to pay is your decision, between you and the site owner; if you’d rather decline, a short reply like the one above keeps the door open. BacklinkGenie itself charges a flat monthly price ($99, $249 or $499) with no per-link fee. How it works shows each step.
Your next step
Find posts you can earn your way onto
The free prospect report lists posts where your product fits, each with a reason and a verified contact. No card needed.
Free, no card. You approve every email before it goes out.
For the full strategy behind earned insertions, go back to the listicle link building hub.
Questions people ask
Is it illegal to pay for a listicle placement?
Paying for advertising isn't illegal. In the US the FTC expects material connections, including payments, to be disclosed clearly when readers wouldn't expect them, and its guides say advertisers can be liable for failing to disclose them. Google's rules are separate and about search, not law: paid links must carry rel=sponsored or nofollow. This is general information, not legal advice.
Will Google penalise my site if a link insertion I paid for is followed?
It can. Google's spam policy lists buying links for ranking purposes as link spam, and says sites that violate its policies may rank lower or not appear at all. Google's systems may also simply ignore such links, so you pay for nothing. The safe options are a rel=sponsored link with a visible label, or not buying.
Do affiliate links pass SEO value?
Usually not much. Many affiliate links run through tracking redirects or carry rel=sponsored or nofollow, which is what Google asks for on paid relationships. Treat affiliate placements as a sales channel. If the same article also mentions you with a plain editorial link that nobody paid for, that link is a separate matter.
What if an editor asks for money after I pitch an insertion?
Decline politely and leave the door open. Many sites send a rate card by default, and some still add products on merit later, often when the post is refreshed. If you do decide to pay, treat it as an ad: ask for a sponsored label and a rel=sponsored link in writing before any money moves.
How long do paid link insertions last?
There's no standard. Some sellers advertise replacement cover for a set period, which tells you removals are common enough to insure against. Paid insertions also tend to disappear when a site cleans up old posts. Whatever kind of insertion you win, re-check the page on a schedule so you know when a link is gone.
Written by
Nikunj Thakkar · Founder, BacklinkGenie
Nikunj builds BacklinkGenie, an outreach agent that pitches editors for links you earn rather than buy. He writes about link outreach, email deliverability and how products end up in the posts people read.
Published · Last updated